Plum Island Provisions. Emerging from the iconic Dick's Variety, this is the newest kid on the block, serving beer and wine and an extensive selection of seafood, pizzas, and sandwiches, along with general supplies and sundries, including newspapers (although the Sunday New York Times often runs out early).

Click here to visit their website, including a very ambitious menu, and here for a Google satellite map/image of downtown (!) Plum Island with the old/new location highlighted.